Tel. 518.584.7640
Open Tues. through Sat. from 5pm | Sundays Open at 4pm
745 Saratoga Road, Wilton, New York 12831
The Wishing Well Saratoga Restaurant Dining Dinner Menu

Make A Reservation

Call 518-584-7640 or book online.


Customer Testimonials


Lobster Dinner at Our Saratoga Springs NY

"One of our favorites. Great menu...something for everyone... They go out of their way to make you feel welcome and comfortable"

OpenTable Review

Fresh Seafood Restaurant Saratoga NY

"Excellent service and food, polite and helpful staff, cozy and intimate atmosphere! A class act!"

T. Williams

Saratoga Fine Dining at The Wishing Well

"Exceptional service, atmosphere and of course the food. Very cool to see such a long time established area favorite evolving with the times! You can see it in the food as well. I could go on and on but the long and short of it is The Wishing Well is best and I will be back very soon. Keep up the great work.

OpenTable Review

Pan Bronzed Sea Scallops

"Loved the Wishing Well. We were promptly seated, the food was above outstanding including the desert. We were a large party and there was not one thing wrong. Everyone in our party enjoyed themselves. We can't wait to come back."

OpenTable Review

Dine at The Wishing WellOur Saratoga Restaurant Dining Dinner Menu

Whether you are looking for a romantic evening or a night with the family, or whether you prefer more creative or traditional American cuisine, the Wishing Well Restaurant offers something for everyone. The atmosphere is comfortable and warm, the people down to earth and the food extraordinary. The delightful music sets a romantic and relaxing atmosphere.

We are pleased to accommodate gluten free and special dietary requests.

Appetizers & Salads

  • Escargot, parsley, tarragon, garlic, 14
  • New England Lobster Bisque, 10
  • Baked French Onion Soup, au gratin, 6
  • Sautéed Tiny Frog Legs, meunière, 12
  • Maryland Crab Cake, fresh dill & sweet corn aioli, 13
  • Littlefield Farms Green Salad, vinaigrette, 7/5 gf
  • Iceberg Wedge Salad, applewood smoked bacon, creamy bleu, chopped tomatoes, 9 gf
  • Classic Caesar Salad, white anchovies, 9/5
  • Grilled Artichokes with olive oil, lemon and mint, 9 gf
  • Flash Fried Calamari, fra diavolo sauce, 10

Raw Bar - Fresh Cold Seafood

  • Chilled Maryland Crab Cocktail, Russian dressing, 16 gf
  • Jumbo White South American Shrimp Cocktail, 16 gf
  • Iced Littleneck Clams on the ½ Shell, 11 gf
  • Fresh Oysters on the ½ Shell, mignonette or spicy cocktail sauce, 14 gf

Three Course Prix Fixe Dinner, 29

Slightly smaller portions of Wishing Well favorites
for those with a lighter appetite.
Choose from three starters, four entrees and three desserts.

First
Caesar Salad, New England Lobster Bisque or Baked French Onion Soup

Second
Center Cut New York Sirloin
Broiled Faroe Island Salmon, lemon caper sauce
Broiled Petite Colorado Lamb Chops, mint chutney
Cider, Garlic & Rosemary Brined Pork Chop, apple relish

Third
New Skete Cheesecake
Smith's Orchard Raspberry Pie
Flourless Chocolate Cake

Lobsters

  • Premium Nova Scotia Lobsters, served steamed, baked with a cornbread & crab stuffing or butter poached out-of-the-shell, market price

Grilled Steaks & Chops

  • Center Cut 8 oz. Filet Mignon, 35
  • Center Cut 14 oz. New York Sirloin, 33
  • Cider, Garlic & Rosemary Brined Pork Chops, apple relish, 27
  • Triple Cut Colorado Lamb Chops, mint chutney, single, 31, twin chops, 49 gf
    • Add a 6 oz South African Lobster Tail, 24 gf
  • Steak Diane, Twin 4 oz. filet mignons, classic cognac sauce, mushrooms & pearl onions, 34
  • Roast Prime Ribs of Beef au Jus
    • Every Saturday
    • Queen Cut, 14 oz., 29, King Cut, 20 oz., 35

Fresh Seafood

  • Pan Seared Colossal Sea Scallops, crispy leeks, tarragon cream, 32 gf
  • Fresh Baked Haddock Oreganata, 23
  • Maryland Crab Cakes, fresh dill & sweet corn aioli, 27
  • Shrimp Scampi, linguine, tomato, parsley, garlic and herbs, 24
  • Twin South African Lobster Tails, mp gf
  • Faroe Islands Salmon and Spring Vegetables, asparagus, peas, mint, 24 gf
  • Lobster Risotto, basil, sun dried tomatoes, shallots, 28

Classics

  • Sauteed Lemon Dill Chicken, capers, penne, 22
  • Roast Maple Leaf Farms Duckling, raspberry bread pudding, blackberry glaze, 29
  • Pan Seared Calves Liver, bacon & onions, 25
  • Chicken Parmesan, linguine, 20
  • The Wishing Well Burger, fresh ground beef, provolone, bacon, onion, lettuce and tomatoes, fries, 14

Entrees served with Chef's Starch & Seasonal Vegetable

Desserts

  • Old Fashioned Strawberry Shortcake, 7
  • Smith’s Orchard Raspberry Pie, 6
  • Flourless Chocolate Cake, raspberry puree, 7
  • Mississippi Mud Pie, 7
  • A Box of Dark Choclate Truffles, 10
    • Made for the Wishing Well by Krauses of Albany
  • Nuns of New Skete Cheesecake, 6
  • Rocky’s Lemon Crème Brulee, 6
  • Warm Chocolate Chip Skillet Cookie, 10
    • Topped with butter pecan ice cream

Ports & Sherries

  • Cockburn Ten Year Tawny, 8
  • Dry Sack, 8
  • Sandeman Founder’s Reserve, 8
  • Harvey’s Bristol Cream, 7
  • Taylor Fladgate Ten Year Tawny, 10

Specialty Coffees

  • Irish, Michael Collins Irish Whiskey, 9
  • Mexican, Kahlua, 9
  • Italian, Sambuca Romana, 9
  • The Coffey Coffee, Remy VS & Kahlua, 10
  • Wishing Well Coffee, Bailey’s, Kahlua, Tia Maria, Cognac, 10

Single Malts

  • Balvenie Doublewood 12
  • Glenfiddich 12 
  • Macallan 12 
  • The Laddie 10
  • Glenlivet 18
  • Port Charlotte
  • The Peat Monster
  • Laphroaig
  • Oban
  • Talisker

Cordials

  • Chambord
  • Bailey’s Irish Cream
  • Banfi Grappa
  • Busnel Calvados, Reserve
  • Luxardo Maraschino
  • Luxardo Amaretto
  • Luxardo Anisette
  • Luxardo Black Sambuca
  • Grand Marnier
  • B & B
  • Drambuie
  • Frangelico
  • Barenjager
  • Tuaca
  • Irish Mist
  • Pernod
  • Galliano
  • Tia Maria
  • Sambuca Romana

Brandies, Cognacs

  • Martell Cordon Bleu, 20
  • Hennessey VS, 10
  • Remy Martin VSOP, 10
  • Germain Robin Craft Method Brandy, 12
  • Germain Robin Select Barrel XO, 25

To download a copy of our menu click here.

Stay Connected


Email Exclusives
Receive monthly email news,
specials, events and more!

Restaurant Hours
Open Tues. - Sat. from 5pm
Sundays Open at 4pm
(closed Monday's except during racing season)


Contact Us
The Wishing Well Restaurant
745 Saratoga Road, Wilton, New York 12831
Reservations 584-7640 | Reserve Online